Study · EUR/USD · breakout

Do EURUSD Breakouts Actually Follow Through? 344 Events, 16 Years

Instrument
EUR/USD
Theme
breakout
Data window
EURUSD · 344 breakout events · 16 years of H1 data
Published
Reading time
6 min

Question & scope

About 63% of qualifying EURUSD breakouts extend and 37% fake out — but that headline hides everything. The size of the breakout candle is the real discriminator: weak breaks fail six times in ten, decisive ones succeed nine in ten.

Key finding · Historical sample

A EURUSD breakout is only a coin-flip-plus until you condition on displacement. Breaks that push less than ~3 pips past the level fake out 60% of the time; breaks that displace hard follow through 90%+ of the time. The candle's conviction, not the level itself, is the signal.

Breakout success rate by displacement (how far the candle pushed past the level)

Displacement past the level · Success rate (%)

Breakout success rate by displacement (how far the candle pushed past the level) — numeric data
Displacement past the levelSuccess rate (%)
0–3 pips40.5%
3–8 pips53.4%
8–15 pips74.3%
15–30 pips91.5%
>30 pips100%
A real EURUSD breakout — 22 Nov 2024, London openH1
breakoutconsolidation low (broken level) · 1.04612

Hollow: close ≥ open · Filled: close < openconsolidation low (broken level)breakout

Price coiled in a tight range through the Asian session, then broke the low with a decisive candle at the London open and ran ~110 pips without looking back — a high-displacement break, the kind that follows through 90%+ of the time.

Candle data
A real EURUSD breakout — 22 Nov 2024, London open — candle data
TimeOpenHighLowClose
2024-11-21 14:001.053271.053541.052071.0535
2024-11-21 15:001.053491.054441.050861.05101
2024-11-21 16:001.0511.051441.047111.0474
2024-11-21 17:001.047381.048761.046191.0487
2024-11-21 18:001.04871.048911.047781.04859
2024-11-21 19:001.048591.04871.047291.04841
2024-11-21 20:001.048411.048651.047761.04786
2024-11-21 21:001.047881.048051.047141.0473
2024-11-21 22:001.046941.04771.046941.04743
2024-11-21 23:001.047441.047671.046731.04688
2024-11-22 00:001.046871.047531.046621.04752
2024-11-22 01:001.047531.047751.04691.04714
2024-11-22 02:001.047141.047291.046681.04725
2024-11-22 03:001.047261.047791.04721.04746
2024-11-22 04:001.047431.047591.046931.04743
2024-11-22 05:001.047431.047431.046121.04643
2024-11-22 06:001.046421.047011.046331.0469
2024-11-22 07:001.04691.04891.04621.04857
2024-11-22 08:001.048581.049791.044081.04434
2024-11-22 09:001.044331.044391.033181.04017
2024-11-22 10:001.040161.043721.038441.04294
2024-11-22 11:001.042931.042961.040791.04161
2024-11-22 12:001.041661.041921.039771.04071
2024-11-22 13:001.040711.043411.04061.04292
2024-11-22 14:001.042921.043441.040171.04036
2024-11-22 15:001.040361.041981.039451.04101
2024-11-22 16:001.041041.041141.039171.0398
2024-11-22 17:001.039811.042011.039791.04187
2024-11-22 18:001.041871.042511.041451.04164
2024-11-22 19:001.041631.041851.040841.04106
2024-11-22 20:001.041051.041711.040771.04142
2024-11-22 21:001.041421.041951.041111.04152
2024-11-24 22:001.047581.048121.046091.04785
2024-11-24 23:001.047851.050091.045891.04789
2024-11-25 00:001.047891.048471.047321.04809
2024-11-25 01:001.048091.048971.047381.04777
2024-11-25 02:001.047751.048911.047431.04865
2024-11-25 03:001.048671.048791.047561.04776
2024-11-25 04:001.047761.048081.047421.04789
2024-11-25 05:001.04791.048281.04751.04788
2024-11-25 06:001.047891.048921.047461.04835
2024-11-25 07:001.048321.048331.044961.04502
2024-11-25 08:001.045011.046691.044881.04649

"Trade the breakout" is one of the oldest instructions in the book, and one of the least examined. We took a strict, mechanical definition of a EURUSD breakout — price closing decisively beyond a tight consolidation — and measured what happened next across every occurrence in 16 years of hourly data: 344 events.

The headline: better than a coin flip, worse than the reputation

OutcomeCountShare
Success (extends cleanly)21763.1%
Fakeout (closes back inside)12736.9%

Sixty-three percent success sounds tradeable — and it is — but a third of breakouts snapping straight back is exactly the experience that makes people distrust the pattern. The average is not the story. The story is which breakouts.

Displacement is the whole game

The single most powerful filter is how hard the breakout candle pushed past the level. The chart above is nearly monotonic:

A limp break that barely clears the level fails more often than it works. A break that displaces decisively past the level succeeds nine or ten times out of ten. This is the "conviction" principle made quantitative — the market either means it or it doesn't, and the size of the move tells you which.

The retest is not the confirmation people think it is

A popular rule says: wait for the breakout to retest the broken level, then enter. The data is blunt about this:

  • 82% of all breakouts retested the level within a few hours.
  • Successful breakouts retested 71% of the time.
  • Fakeouts retested 100% of the time.

Because winners and losers both retest, the retest itself carries almost no information. What matters is what happens at the retest — does the level hold, or does price close back through it? The retest is a decision point, not a green light.

Timing and compression tilt the odds

Two context filters moved the numbers meaningfully:

  • Session timing. Breakouts during the London-open window (roughly 07:00–08:00 UTC) succeeded ~70–72% of the time; breakouts in the quiet Asian session succeeded only ~52%. Liquidity has to be present for a break to run.
  • Compression tightness. The tighter the consolidation before the break, the higher the success and the larger the follow-through — the "coiled spring" thesis holds up in the data.

What this means

The exact entry, stop, and target parameters we run stay in the engine — a published edge is a dead edge. But the durable lessons transfer to any instrument:

  • A breakout is a claim; displacement is the evidence. Size the candle before you trust the level.
  • The retest tells you almost nothing on its own — only its outcome does.
  • Breakouts need liquidity to run. The same pattern is worth far less in a dead session than at the London open.

Sixty-three percent becomes something much better once you refuse to take the weak ones. That refusal — not the entry trigger — is the edge.