Study · S&P 500 · gaps

Does the S&P 500 Fill Its Gaps? It Depends Entirely on Size

Instrument
S&P 500
Theme
gaps
Data window
S&P 500 · 418 gap events · 2024–2026
Published
Reading time
5 min

Question & scope

Small S&P 500 gaps fill almost every time; large gaps mostly don't. Across 418 gap events, sub-5-point gaps filled 96% of the session while gaps over 50 points filled just 20% — the size of the gap decides whether it's noise or signal.

Key finding · Historical sample

S&P 500 gap-fill probability is a near-monotonic function of gap size. Tiny gaps (<5 pts) fill ~96% of the session and are noise to fade; large gaps (>50 pts) fill only ~20% and extend — they are signal to follow. Relative to ATR the split is even cleaner: under 0.25× ATR fills 94%, over 2× ATR fills 9%.

Same-session gap-fill rate by gap size

Gap size (points) · Filled same session (%)

Same-session gap-fill rate by gap size — numeric data
Gap size (points)Filled same session (%)
0–5 pts95.9%
5–10 pts78.6%
10–25 pts59.7%
25–50 pts35.9%
>50 pts20.4%
A real S&P 500 gap that didn't fill — 24 Jul 2024D1
gap downprior close (fill target) · 5559.43

Hollow: close ≥ open · Filled: close < openprior close (fill target)gap down

The S&P gapped down ~76 points (over 3× ATR) and kept going — it didn't fill that session and was still below the prior close a full week later. A textbook 'large gap is signal, not noise': big gaps extend far more often than they fill.

Candle data
A real S&P 500 gap that didn't fill — 24 Jul 2024 — candle data
TimeOpenHighLowClose
2024-07-105629.815654.365576.595586.15
2024-07-115587.035655.675570.335615.83
2024-07-145628.835667.115613.455636.41
2024-07-155636.415669.995621.85664.27
2024-07-165663.525666.265581.735592.15
2024-07-175593.875614.545522.275553.42
2024-07-185555.935560.985495.925504.87
2024-07-215506.325569.985506.325561.67
2024-07-225562.125585.225543.125559.43
2024-07-235557.55557.55420.025440.17
2024-07-245441.125491.925391.025401.75
2024-07-255403.585489.325403.585460.03
2024-07-285460.225495.885443.785467.03
2024-07-295467.725491.125395.275417.43
2024-07-305414.755551.425414.385531.73
2024-07-315533.685564.425409.085436.27
2024-08-015435.485437.95299.485329.47
2024-08-045299.853145090.625216.93

"The gap always fills" is received wisdom on the S&P 500. Like most received wisdom, it's true right up until it costs you. We measured every overnight gap — the cash open versus the prior cash close — across 418 sessions and asked a simple question: does it fill, and what decides it?

Size is the whole answer

Gap sizeFilled same session
0–5 pts95.9%
5–10 pts78.6%
10–25 pts59.7%
25–50 pts35.9%
>50 pts20.4%

The relationship is almost a straight line down. Small gaps are noise — the market opens a few points off and drifts back to fair value within the session nine or nineteen times out of twenty. Large gaps are signal — something repriced overnight, and price extends away from the prior close rather than returning to it. Above 50 points, "the gap always fills" is simply false four times out of five.

Relative size is even sharper than absolute size

Points alone don't account for how volatile the tape is. Measured against the day's ATR, the split is starker still:

Gap vs ATRFilled same session
< 0.25× ATR94.4%
0.25–0.5× ATR79.5%
0.5–1× ATR56.6%
1–2× ATR31.9%
> 2× ATR9.1%

A gap larger than twice the average range fills barely 9% of the session. In volatility terms, a big gap is a regime statement, not a mean-reversion opportunity.

Even the stubborn ones mostly fill — eventually

Widen the window to five sessions and most gaps do close — the small ones (~92%), the mid ones (~76%) — but the largest gaps still only fill about 43% of the time even over a week. A >50-point gap is not a "wait for it" trade; roughly half of them never come back.

A small directional wrinkle

Up-gaps and down-gaps behave similarly at small sizes, but large up-gaps extended slightly more often than large down-gaps — consistent with an equity market that trends up and gaps up on genuine strength. Day of week mattered at the margin too: Monday carried the largest gaps, Friday the smallest, as weekend positioning built and unwound.

What this means

The precise fade/follow thresholds we trade stay private, but the framework is simple and general:

  • Gap size is the signal-vs-noise dial. Small gaps fade; large gaps follow. There is no single "gaps fill" rule — there's a curve.
  • Scale the gap to volatility, not just to points. Against ATR the fill probability is even more decisive.
  • Large gaps are regime statements. Half of the biggest ones never fill, even over a week — don't marry the mean-reversion trade.

The edge isn't knowing that gaps fill. It's knowing the exact point on the size curve where "fade it" flips to "follow it."